FinObservatory

Rate of return on everything

Italy

What one unit of currency became

Invested in 1928 and held to 2020, after inflation. Equities ended at 21.6x, housing at 38.8x, bonds at 10.2x and bills at 2.5x. The scale is logarithmic, because over a century of compounding a linear axis would flatten three of these four lines into the floor. The dashed line is 1.0: below it, the asset lost purchasing power.

1x10x19501975200022x39x10x2.5x
EquitiesHousingBondsBillsbanking crisis (JST)

Source: Jorda-Schularick-Taylor Macrohistory Database, Release 6 (Jorda, Knoll, Kuvshinov, Schularick & Taylor) Compounded over the 86 years in which all four assets were reported. 7 years inside the 1928-2020 window are missing at least one asset and are skipped, so the series is not an unbroken run of 93 years. Shaded bars are JST's own banking-crisis years. Methodology

Compound annual real return

AssetReal returnExcluding the warsVolatilityObservationsSpan
Equities2.44%3.89%25.891501871-2020
Housing4.34%4.34%9.34861928-2020
Bonds0.49%3.47%14.531501871-2020
Bills-0.36%1.91%10.301301871-2020

Source: Jorda-Schularick-Taylor Macrohistory Database, Release 6 (Jorda, Knoll, Kuvshinov, Schularick & Taylor) Nominal returns deflated by JST's own consumer price index. No observation for this country is flagged as interpolated. Methodology

An independent check on the safe rate

Two scholars, two sources, one quantity. The bill rate computed here, deflated by JST's price index, set against Schmelzing's independently constructed real safe rate for the same country-years. They are built from different underlying instruments and are not expected to match to the decimal; where they track each other, both are more credible. This check exists for eight countries only, because Schmelzing's country series covers no others, and it is shown where it exists rather than promised everywhere.

PeriodJST real bill rateSchmelzing real safe rate
1870-191343 yr3.91%4.80%
1919-193820 yr5.67%-0.47%
1946-197934 yr-1.31%-0.75%
1980-201839 yr2.07%3.63%

Source: Jorda-Schularick-Taylor Macrohistory Database, Release 6 (Jorda, Knoll, Kuvshinov, Schularick & Taylor) | Schmelzing (2020), Bank of England Staff Working Paper 845 Arithmetic mean of the annual real rate within each period, over the years both sources report. Periods split at the wars. Methodology

Coverage for Italy

Equities 151 years, housing 86, bonds 151, bills 131. JST flags 9 banking crisis years for this country, marked on the chart. An average taken over a short series is a weaker statistic than one taken over a long series, and the counts are here so you can tell which you are reading.

Methodology